CGI(Common Gateway Interface) vs SERVLETS

Info_Tech_and_Solutions

Servlet is a small Java program that runs within a Web server.Servlets receive and respond to requests from Web clients, usually across HTTP, the HyperText Transfer Protocol.

Common Gateway Interface (CGI) is a standard environment for web servers to interface with executable programs installed on a server that generate web pages dynamically.

  • Servlets can link directly to the Web server.
CGI cannot directly link to Web server.
  • Servlets can share data among each other.
CGI does not provide sharing property.
  • Servlets can perform session tracking and caching of previous computations.
CGI cannot perform session tracking and caching of previous computations.
  • Servlets are portable.
CGI is not portable.
  • In Servlets, the Java Virtual Machine stays up, and each request is handled by a lightweight Java thread.
In CGI, each request is handled by a heavyweight operating system process.
  • Servlets automatically parse and decode the HTML form data.
CGI cannot automatically parse and decode the HTML form data.
  • Servlets can read and set HTTP headers, handle cookies, tracking sessions.
CGI cannot read and set HTTP headers, handle cookies, tracking sessions.
  • Servlets is inexpensive than CGI.
CGI is more expensive than Servlets

CGIfc01

Both are server-side technologies, but CGI programs execute in their own shell, at run-time they create there own shell, and it involves an heavy weight activity. but where as servlets can be requested using different threads.

Advantages of CGI:
Can be written in variety of languages ,primarily written in perl
Bugs does not crash the web server
Easy for reference
Execute in their own OS Shell, doesn’t have concurrency conflicts
All service providers support CGI Programs

Disadvantages:
Response time is high, the creation of an OS Shell is an heavy weight activity
CGI is not scalable
Not always secure or object-oriented
No separation of presentation and business logic
Scripting languages are often platform-dependent

Advantages of servlets over CGI
Request is run in a separate thread,so faster than CGIs
Scalable,can serve many more requests,
Robust and Object Oriented.
Can be written in Java Programming language.
Platform independent.
Access to Logging Capabilities.

Error handling and Security.

1.CGI creates a new process for each request Whereas Servlet creates a thread for each request and services the request in that thread.

2.For each process created by CGI the process is assinged seperate address space.SO there is memory overload on the server.Whereas for every thread created by the servlet no seperate address space is created all threads operate in the same parent process address space.so there is no memory overlaod.

3.CGI is not based on pooling Whereas servlet are container managed pooled objects.

cgi and servlets are used to develop webapplication only.cgi is a oldest technique .the main drawback of cgi is

  1. starting process is very expensive

  2. it performs very poor.

1) performance,
2) portability,
3) error handling,
4) session management, and
5) access to and ability to extend the server itself.

Platform Independence
Servlets are written entirely in java so these are platform independent. Servlets can run on any Servlet enabled web server. For example if you develop an web application in windows machine running Java web server, you can easily run the same on apache web server (if Apache Serve is installed) without modification or compilation of code. Platform independency of servlets provide a great advantages over alternatives of servlets.
Performance
Due to interpreted nature of java, programs written in java are slow. But the java servlets runs very fast. These are due to the way servlets run on web server. For any program initialization takes significant amount of time. But in case of servlets initialization takes place first time it receives a request and remains in memory till times out or server shut downs. After servlet is loaded, to handle a new request it simply creates a new thread and runs service method of servlet. In comparison to traditional CGI scripts which creates a new process to serve the request.
Extensibility
Java Servlets are developed in java which is robust, well-designed and object oriented language which can be extended or polymorphed into new objects. So the java servlets take all these advantages and can be extended from existing class to provide the ideal solutions.
Safety
Java provides very good safety features like memory management, exception handling etc. Servlets inherits all these features and emerged as a very powerful web server extension.
Secure
Servlets are server side components, so it inherits the security provided by the web server. Servlets are also benefited with Java Security Manager .

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s